He enjoyed the cake, but he ate it pretty delicately (which was unexpected).
He loved his presents, and was especially thrilled with the tricycle with the G license plate.
We did a modified pinata where the kids just pulled the strings out from the bottom with the idea that the candy would fall out on its own, minus any blindfolded bat-swinging. Unfortunately, the packages were too big and when we pulled the strings, nothing came out. Very anticlimactic.
And what did Graham grab during the resulting melee? Not candy or cookies... Just the popsicle stick that held the pinata.
I think it's safe to say that everyone had fun, but we've decided never to have such a production again. His birthday memories from now on will consist of McDonald's and Chuck E Cheese, if he's lucky.
Thanks to everyone who was able to come and be a part of it!